Zoey (I Dare You Book 2) Read online

  Rafe put on the charm and raised her hand to his lips for a kiss. He smiled when he noticed her biting her bottom lip. Oh yeah, baby. I know you want me. “I’m not one to beat around the bush, so I’m just going to come out and say it. Heidi, Nathan, and I are looking for a woman to join us. Interested?”

  “Heidi know what you’re up to here?” Zoey turned to look in the direction of her friend, and her expression changed from shock to interest. Her eyes became hooded, and the corner of her mouth quirked up in a slight smile.

  “Who do you think suggested it?” he challenged.

  She blushed, and right then Heidi approached, and it gave her a minute to compose herself.

  “Suggested what?” Heidi asked as Nathan pulled her chair out like a gentleman.

  Zoey’s eyes were on Rafe when she answered. “Apparently, Rafe here would like me to fulfill that dare we were talking about earlier and has suggested that you might have brought it up.”

  Heidi’s confusion turned into comprehension when Zoey finally looked at her, and she clapped her hands enthusiastically. “Well, we talked about it, but we never discussed with whom. Oh my God, Zo, it would be perfect. Dare complete for you and fun times for all of us.”

  “Are you sure about this?”

  “Oh yeah, baby, of course she is,” Rafe said. When Zoey looked at her friend again, she was nodding her consent. “I wouldn’t have said so otherwise. Shall we have a few more drinks first? Or maybe you’d like to leave here and consider making some great memories for later on?” He leaned towards her to whisper in her ear. “Have you ever had two guys at once, baby? Or another woman to play with? How about all of the above? Think about it.”

  He pulled back in time to gauge her expression as she absorbed what he’d just said. He could pinpoint the moment it clicked.

  Oh, fuck yeah!

  “Sounds pretty intriguing. Nathan, you’ve been pretty quiet.”

  He shrugged. “I’m in if Heidi approves, and apparently she does. The thought of you with us is hot as hell. You in?”

  “In.” Zoey nodded and chugged half of her drink. “Let’s go before I chicken out.”

  Rafe chuckled and watched the sway of her curvaceous ass as she retreated before he followed his two—soon to be three—lovers as they headed to the door. All was right in the world. He had the two people he loved beside him, and some fun times in the next hour or two to look forward to. Life was good.

  ****

  “Holy shit, would you look at that?” Nathan moaned and couldn’t contain himself anymore. His cock was so hard it felt like it was about to bust through his zipper. He tried adjusting himself, but it was no use. If he couldn’t spring his chubby soon, he’d have a permanent imprint of the metal enclosure on the head of his dick forever, or at least that was how it felt. It was a bittersweet pain but so totally worth the outcome. Heidi, my sweet, beautiful Goddess…

  “It’s fucking hot is what it is. I’ve never been so horny in my life.” Rafe growled, and Nathan couldn’t contain himself any longer. He reached down and unzipped his jeans to free his cock.

  Heidi and Zoey were already completely naked and on the bed in front of them. Their hands groped, tweaked, and fondled each other, and their mouths were joined in a passionate kiss. It made a good show for Rafe and Nathan as they watched. This had been a fantasy of Heidi’s for quite some time, and Nathan and Rafe both knew she loved the power she had over them when they were turned on—she’d told them about it.

  When they’d gotten back to the apartment, she had slowly undressed Zoey before getting naked herself, and it hadn’t taken Zoey very long to go along with it.

  “Fuck, we have the most amazing woman in the world,” Nathan blurted out, and decided it was time to ease their ache a little.

  “Yeah, and thanks for sharing her with me,” Rafe said, and they both smiled at each other.

  Nathan turned to close the distance between the two men. His hand slowly made its way down to Rafe’s pants and began to stroke him the moment his erection sprang free.

  “Keep it up and I’m going to come.”

  “Good,” Nathan said, but it came out a little strained as Rafe reached over to reciprocate. They began to pump their hips and fucked each other’s hands until Nathan grew impatient again. He placed his other hand on top of Rafe’s to stop the jack-off session and then fell to his knees in front of him.

  “What are you doing? I thought we were going to watch.”

  “We are, but I’m about to come all over my jeans if I keep watching right now. So I propose we take the edge off a little. What do you say? You watch them while I suck you, and once you come, you do the same to me and give me mine. If you’re as excited as I am right now, it shouldn’t take very long. Plus, it’ll give us a better chance to enjoy the women once they’re finished playing with each other.”

  “Yeah, we won’t come so damn fast the next time.” Rafe thrust his hips forward so the tip of his cock brushed against Nathan’s lips, and he had his answer. “Suck my cock, Nathan, because you’re not coming until I do it first. Earn it, baby.”

  Nathan chuckled.

  Rafe’s fingers tangled in his lover’s hair, and Nathan groaned as he got down to business. Pre-cum dripped from the head of Rafe’s cock, and he decided to taste that first with a smooth lick to the tip. His tongue swirled around the head of Rafe’s fat penis a few times before Nathan finally wrapped his lips around it and took him fully. His head bobbed back and forth in motion with his hand as it stroked at the base. Rafe began to thrust his hips at a leisurely pace. “Fuck, I love the way your mouth feels.”

  Nathan looked up to see the rise and fall of Rafe’s chest. His eyes were on the ladies in front of them, and his thrusts became deeper, fucking Nathan’s mouth. He could feel the tip of Rafe’s cock at the back of his throat, and Nathan knew he was close to officially tasting him fully.

  He moaned, and Rafe gasped, finally looking at him. His hands tightened in Nathan’s hair. “Do that again. It feels good when you moan. I can feel the vibrations straight up my cock.”

  Nathan pulled back with a pop, smiled, and began to lick him again. “You like that, huh?” He moaned as his tongue worked its way down the underside of Rafe’s shaft, from the base to the tip. “Come for me, Rafe. I’m aching over here.” His hands grasped Rafe’s hips as he placed his mouth back on him, deep-throating. He sucked harder, licked, and moaned for him again like requested, but instead of stroking him this time, he coaxed the other man’s hips to go faster.

  “Yes,” Rafe hissed. “Here it comes, baby.” His cock jerked, and spurts of warm, salty cum hit the back of Nathan’s throat. His hips continued to pump until he was sucked clean, and he collapsed against the wall behind him to catch his breath.

  “My turn.” Nathan stood with a spring in his step. “Now on your knees and worship me.”

  “Now that’s the Nathan we know and love,” Rafe teased, and dropped in front of him. “But we all love your take-charge attitude. You’re a man who knows what he likes and how he likes it. Direct me anytime you like.” He sent him another smile and then winked.

  “Good. Now less talking and more sucking.” He stroked his own cock a couple of times before placing it in front of the other man’s mouth. He was so turned on it was painful, and Nathan’s body spasmed a little the moment the wet warmth of Rafe’s delectable mouth surrounded his dick. “Shit!” Take it slow, Nathan, no matter how fucking good this feels. Enjoy it a little. I am not going to come yet. I am not going to come yet. Fuck!

  “Hey, I thought you guys were supposed to watch.” Heidi smiled, and Zoey gasped at the sight of them.

  “We’re taking turns.” Nathan winked. “The sight of the two of you together got us so fucking worked up we needed a little release. We’re enjoying the show, though, sweetheart. Now make it good for me.” He decided that instead of concentrating on how good his dick felt, he’d concentrate on Heidi and Zoey again. He tugged on Rafe’s hair and forced him to look up. �
�Lick me, Rafe. I’m about ready to come, and I want to enjoy this a little longer. Take it slow, yeah.”

  Rafe nodded with a smile and got back to work, going slower this time. His tongue swirled down his shaft from the tip to the base, going lower, and once his lips reached Nathan’s balls, Nathan hissed and gave into the reflex to thrust forward again.

  Rafe’s enthusiasm started to build as he worked Nathan’s cock. They’d been together enough times now that Rafe knew what Nathan liked and just how he liked it.

  Nathan finally took his eyes away from Rafe and pinned them on Heidi as she was just about to mount Zoey. The other woman lay on her back in the middle of the bed, while Heidi crawled on top of her facing in the opposite direction, pussy to face for each of them. She looked Nathan in the eye with a smirk and pressed her ass closer to Zoey’s face. He moaned and bit his lip, almost wishing that it was him doing the tasting of her. She was so fucking amazing—his addiction, his drug, and right then she had him hypnotized.

  Meanwhile, Rafe began to take him fully again. He could feel the man’s lips all the way to the root, could feel his sensitive head tapping the back of Rafe’s throat as he sucked him with enthusiasm, but it was Heidi’s actions that had him utterly in a trance. He couldn’t tear his gaze away.

  Her hands rested on Zoey’s thighs, spreading her as far as she would go, and it bared her pussy for all to see. Heidi’s tongue slowly slid through her friend’s glistening pink folds to get a good taste of her before she went in for the kill. Her tongue licked, flicked, and then began to fuck Zoey’s opening, making the woman moan and push her hips forward in her haste for completion. Nathan smiled fondly and was so proud of his woman. She was living yet another fantasy, and he’d bet she was just about ready to come. Hell, he was too.

  “Make her come, Heidi, and then I want to hear you scream for me.” He spoke through a clenched jaw, and he couldn’t hold back any longer. His hands tightened in Rafe’s hair and his ass tightened while he fucked his mouth harder.

  “Okay Rafe, this is it. Taste me, baby. Take every fucking drop of me.” He held his lover’s head still once his cock began to jerk and watched Rafe’s cheeks move as he took everything Nathan had to give him. Now they were both temporarily sated, but it wouldn’t be long before they’d be ready for round two. Rafe wiped his mouth and finally stood up again, and both men moved closer to watch the women fulfill their own completion.

  As instructed, Heidi’s tongue gently stroked Zoey’s clit, driving the woman wild with need. Heidi’s own whimper could be heard through her friend’s rapid breathing and panting.

  Rafe nudged Nathan and tilted his head to the side. “Think they’ll come at the same time?”

  They both smiled wide.

  “I think it’ll be a close call.” Nathan began to stroke his cock, which was already becoming erect again, and held back a chuckle as Rafe mimicked his movement by doing the same to his own. Both men concentrated on the show in front of them.

  Heidi’s head bobbed slightly, her hands squeezing the flesh on Zoey’s thighs now as her own excitement began to build. Zoey’s panting soon turned into a scream as she came, and Heidi’s mouth moved quicker to try to drink all of her juices.

  “Your turn.” Zoey’s breathless voice filled the room, and her hold seemed to tighten around their woman’s hips.

  Heidi looked up, locking gazes with first Rafe and then Nathan. She sat up a little. “Rafe, Nathan, come here.” She beckoned them closer with her plea. Both men moved forward until they stood in front of the bed.

  Rafe reached for her first and lightly pressed his lips against hers. One peck, and he groaned. “How fucking hot is that? I could taste her on you.” He sucked on her bottom lip, and she began to grind her hips against Zoey’s face.

  She arched her head back, and he began to kiss down her neck until he reached her nipples. “Holy shit, God, Zo like that. Don’t stop, honey. Please don’t stop.” She reached for Rafe and held him to her.

  Meanwhile, Nathan stood beside them admiring the erotic view. “Are you about to come, Heidi? Because I want to see that pretty pussy when you do. Pulse for us, baby, and let her taste your cream.”

  “Yes.” Heidi nodded. “Yes, Nathan, oh God. Yessss…”

  Nathan knelt on the bed and leaned over so that his face was just above Zoey’s, staring directly at Heidi’s pussy and ass. The moment she screamed out, Nathan couldn’t help himself. He could smell the arousal of all four of them mixed together, and it drove him wild. He positioned himself so that he and Zoey both tasted her. Their tongues touched and caressed each other as they lapped up Heidi’s release, and he moaned while loving the taste of them both. It was a unique mixture of Heidi with this new woman in their bed.

  Zoey’s head turned, and before he knew it, they were entwined in a passionate kiss. Her hands slid off of Heidi’s hips and moved into his hair, and it was only when she pressed fully against him that he realized Heidi had moved away.

  He wanted her.

  Nathan pulled back breathlessly and began to look for her. Right beside them, only about a foot away, Heidi was in Rafe’s embrace doing exactly what Nathan was to Zoey.

  Zoey whimpered, snuggling closer. “I need to be filled, Nathan.” She moved her hips and aligned herself right against his hard cock. She began to rub her pussy against it eagerly.

  “Patience, sweets. We’ll fill you both up nice and good as soon as Rafe and I get some condoms on.” He moved from the bed momentarily to his top dresser drawer, and Rafe followed.

  Both women sat up and admired their view, watching closely.

  “You’re one lucky woman,” Zoey sighed, and then smiled as both men approached them ready to go.

  “I don’t disagree.” Heidi winked, and Nathan laughed.

  “Actually, I think that I’m the one who lucked out. My best friend turned out to be the woman of my dreams, and I love her more than anything. Then the bonus came when our neighbor and good friend joined us and we fell in love again. The three of us complete each other nicely, don’t you think?”

  Heidi and Rafe both smiled.

  “I do,” Zoey agreed.

  “Thank you for fulfilling one of our fantasies, both yours and mine, Zo. I always wanted to know what it would be like with another woman, and what better way than to share you with the two most important people in my life?”

  Nathan smiled and stroked his cock. “Now I think it’s time we fill you both.”

  “I think I’d like that.” Zoey’s eyes sparkled as she eyed Rafe’s cock, and she licked her lips.

  “Good, now Rafe, why don’t you sample our guest while I make love to Heidi? I’m aching to feel her pussy wrapped around me again. You good with that?”

  “Oh yeah.” Rafe reached for Zoey and brought her body against his as he stood in front of the bed. “On your knees, sweetheart. Head down and ass up.”

  “Okay.” She eagerly positioned herself and arched back as Rafe entered her right to the hilt. He fucked her hard and fast and enjoyed every minute of it, while Nathan took a more tender approach with Heidi as she faced him and he took his time savoring her.

  It was pure rated-R bliss.

  ****

  Present

  It was a fond memory of their last night in Port Jervis, before they left Rafe behind temporarily to move to Long Island City. Nathan had been offered the job of his dreams working for Muse Marketing, a big-time ad agency. He’d taken Heidi with him, of course, and he couldn’t help but think of the last good time they’d had knowing that Rafe was going to be there with them again come morning—and for good this time.

  With a few loose ends to tie up in Port Jervis, Rafe had finally decided he missed them enough to move in with them, and they couldn’t be happier.

  As Nathan lay in bed, he had to convince himself to try and get some sleep so tomorrow would come faster.

  “You okay?” Heidi snuggled closer. “You zoned out for a few minutes there.”

  “Yeah.” Nathan sm
iled and put his arm around her as she rested her head against his chest. “I was just thinking about Rafe and our last night in Port Jervis.”

  “Mmm, what a great memory. I can’t wait to see him tomorrow.” She sighed and moved to rest her chin on his chest so she could look at him. “I know we visited with him last week, but I miss him.”

  “Me too.” Nathan began to play with her hair. “He’ll be here in the morning, though, and in the meantime, why don’t we make some memories between the two of us right now?”

  “I like the sound of that.” She squealed in delight when he flipped her over so that he was on top of her now, and she wrapped her legs around him once he entered her. “I love you, Nathan.”

  “And I love you,” he whispered back, before lowering himself to meet her lips against his own. And as they made love that night, Nathan knew their love extended to the man they both missed. There wasn’t a huge distance between their two cities, but it wasn’t the same as always having him near. It would soon change for the better, and in a few short hours, they’d be a trio once more.

  Nathan couldn’t wait.

  Chapter Two

  “I can’t believe you’re finally here!” Heidi threw open the door and squealed. She immediately jumped into Rafe’s arms and wrapped herself around him. “I missed you so much.”

  “Me too, beautiful. It feels like it’s been way too long.” He chuckled, and she showered him with kisses all over his face.

  “Hold on tight, sweetheart. I’ve got to get my bag.” He draped one arm protectively around her waist while he bent down to retrieve the luggage he’d dropped.

  He finally walked inside and kicked the door shut behind them. The new condo had a nice open concept to it. From what he could see, it was quite spacious. There was a large eat-in kitchen with an island in the middle, and beside it was the living room. It had a ton of natural light coming through a few large windows, and he liked the view of the city coming from it; it looked busier than Port Jervis. From where he stood, he could see the stairs leading to what he presumed were the bedrooms.